Winter Garden 34787 vs Ocoee 34761: November 2026 Neighborhood Prices
Ocoee is the lower-cost choice next door to Winter Garden this fall. In October 2026, the median list price in Ocoee ZIP 34761 was $439,856, about $144,000 below the $583,950 median in Winter Garden ZIP 34787, according to Realtor.com. Ocoee homes were also listed for less per square foot, $223 versus $256, and sold faster, with a median of 71 days on market against 79 in Winter Garden.
Winter Garden has far more to choose from. Realtor.com counted 635 active listings in 34787 in October 2026, about five times the 128 in 34761. Below, Bella Trae Realty compares the two ZIP codes on price, inventory, rent and monthly payment, and walks through the neighborhoods buyers ask us about most on each side of the line.
Winter Garden 34787 vs Ocoee 34761: Prices at a Glance, November 2026
We used three public data sets: the Realtor.com ZIP-level listing data for October 2026, the Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) for September 2026, and the Zillow Observed Rent Index (ZORI) for September 2026. ZIP 34787 covers downtown Winter Garden and much of Horizon West, so the Winter Garden numbers blend older in-town homes with newer master-planned villages.
| Measure | Winter Garden 34787 | Ocoee 34761 |
|---|---|---|
| Median list price (Realtor.com, Oct 2026) | $583,950 | $439,856 |
| Change in median list price, year over year | -5.0% | -3.5% |
| Median list price per sq ft | $256 | $223 |
| Median listing size | 2,129 sq ft | 1,898 sq ft |
| Typical home value (Zillow ZHVI, Sep 2026) | $573,339 | $410,953 |
| Change in typical value, year over year | -0.4% | -1.0% |
| Active listings (Oct 2026) | 635 | 128 |
| New listings in October 2026 | 180 | 48 |
| Median days on market | 79 | 71 |
| Share of listings with a price cut | 21.3% | 17.9% |
| Typical rent (Zillow ZORI, Sep 2026) | $2,249 | $2,151 |
Two things stand out. Asking prices in both ZIPs are lower than a year ago, with Winter Garden down more. And the typical home value from Zillow barely moved in either ZIP over the same year, which suggests sellers are trimming asking prices toward where homes actually trade.
What the Price Gap Means for a Monthly Payment
Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% on November 12, 2026, down from 7.24% on October 29. At that rate, here is principal and interest alone on each ZIP's median list price:
- Winter Garden 34787 at $583,950: about $3,143 a month with 20% down, or about $3,535 with 10% down.
- Ocoee 34761 at $439,856: about $2,367 a month with 20% down, or about $2,663 with 10% down.
That is a gap of roughly $776 to $872 a month before property taxes, insurance and any HOA or CDD fees. Those extra costs vary a lot by street. Newer Horizon West villages often carry CDD assessments on the tax bill, while many older Ocoee and downtown Winter Garden subdivisions do not. Ask for the actual tax bill and HOA budget on any home you are serious about.
For buyers who are close to the top of their budget in Winter Garden, Ocoee is often the first place we look next. The commute to downtown Orlando is similar or shorter, and the West Orange Trail runs through both cities.
Where to Look in Winter Garden 34787
Winter Garden buyers usually choose between two very different settings inside the same ZIP code.
Downtown and the Plant Street area. Homes within walking or biking distance of Plant Street are a mix of older bungalows, renovated cottages and infill new builds. Lots are smaller and inventory is thin, so good homes here tend to draw attention even in a slower market. The draw is the downtown farmers market, restaurants and direct access to the West Orange Trail.
Horizon West villages. South of downtown, Horizon West villages such as Hamlin, Summerlake and Lakeshore are newer, master-planned and amenity heavy, with pools, parks and walkable town centers. Much of the 635-listing count in 34787 sits here, including new construction from national builders. That supply is a big reason Winter Garden asking prices have come down and price cuts are more common.
Lake and acreage pockets. Homes near Johns Lake and Lake Apopka's south shore offer bigger lots and water views at higher prices. These trade less often and are priced home by home.
Where to Look in Ocoee 34761
Ocoee sits just east of Winter Garden along State Road 50, with quick access to SR 429, the Florida Turnpike and SR 408. Its housing is mostly resale single-family homes from the 1980s through the 2000s, plus newer pockets on the north side.
Lake Starke and the downtown core. The area around Lake Starke and Bluford Avenue has older, smaller homes on established lots, close to the lakefront park and the West Orange Trail.
Westyn Bay and Wesmere. These amenity communities give buyers a newer-home feel, with community pools and clubhouses. Compare price per square foot with similar Horizon West homes before you decide.
Arden Park and the north side. Newer construction on Ocoee's north side appeals to buyers who want a newer home and are comparing it with Winter Garden pricing.
Orlando Health Health Central Hospital and West Oaks Mall are both in Ocoee, which matters to buyers who want daily errands and medical care close by.
Renting vs Buying in Each ZIP
Rents are much closer together than prices. Zillow's typical rent was $2,249 in 34787 and $2,151 in 34761 in September 2026, a gap of about $100 a month. Both were slightly lower than a year earlier, down 1.2% in Winter Garden and 0.3% in Ocoee.
With typical rent near $2,150 and principal and interest on a median Ocoee listing near $2,367 with 20% down, buying in Ocoee is within a few hundred dollars of renting once you set aside taxes and insurance. In Winter Garden, the same comparison is about $900 a month apart before those costs. For owners thinking about holding a home as a rental, that rent-to-price math favors Ocoee. Bella Trae Realty's property management team can run rent numbers on a specific address for you.
Which ZIP Fits Your Search
- Choose Winter Garden 34787 if you want the most selection, newer amenity communities in Horizon West, or a walkable home near Plant Street, and your budget is comfortably above $550,000.
- Choose Ocoee 34761 if you want a lower price per square foot, faster-moving resale inventory and quick highway access, and you are fine with an older home or a smaller amenity package.
- Look at both if you are in the $450,000 to $550,000 range. That is where the two ZIPs overlap most, and where negotiating room on a Winter Garden listing can close part of the gap.
In a market where about one in five Winter Garden listings has taken a price cut, buyers have room to ask for seller credits, rate buydowns or repairs. Sellers in both ZIPs are pricing closer to Zillow's typical values, so a well-priced home still draws offers.
Contact Bella Trae Realty today for a ZIP-by-ZIP search of Winter Garden and Ocoee homes that fit your budget. Visit bellatraerealty.com or call (407) 557-8959.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ocoee cheaper than Winter Garden in November 2026?
Yes. The median list price in Ocoee ZIP 34761 was $439,856 in October 2026, compared with $583,950 in Winter Garden ZIP 34787, according to Realtor.com. Ocoee was also lower per square foot, at $223 versus $256.
Are home prices dropping in Winter Garden FL?
Asking prices are. The Realtor.com median list price in 34787 was down 5.0% year over year in October 2026, and 21.3% of listings had a price cut. Zillow's typical home value was nearly flat, down 0.4% year over year as of September 2026.
Which sells faster, Winter Garden or Ocoee?
Ocoee. The median days on market in October 2026 was 71 in 34761 and 79 in 34787. Winter Garden also had about five times as many active listings, 635 versus 128.
How much is a mortgage payment on a median Winter Garden home?
At Freddie Mac's 7.11% average 30-year rate on November 12, 2026, principal and interest on the $583,950 median list price is about $3,143 a month with 20% down. The same math on Ocoee's $439,856 median is about $2,367 a month.
Is rent much different in Winter Garden and Ocoee?
Not much. Zillow's typical rent in September 2026 was $2,249 in 34787 and $2,151 in 34761, about $100 a month apart.
Sources: Realtor.com Residential Data, ZIP-level core metrics, October 2026; Zillow Home Value Index and Zillow Observed Rent Index, ZIP level, September 2026; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey, November 12, 2026. Payment estimates are ours and include principal and interest only.
Rebecca Redman-Hamaoui is the broker and owner of Bella Trae Realty, specializing in residential real estate sales and property management across Winter Garden, Windermere, Clermont, Davenport, and Kissimmee. Contact Bella Trae Realty at bellatraerealty.com for expert guidance.
Categories
Recent Posts









GET MORE INFORMATION

